Shifting power along the insurance value chain
Key Takeaways
Summary
As insurance distributors – such as advisers, brokers, banks and affiliated agents that connect insurers with people – gain scale and negotiating power through consolidation, the channels insurers rely on to reach people seeking financial protection are becoming more concentrated. This means that the terms on which insurers secure customer access are becoming more important.
Key facts & figures
-
More than 300 acquisitions
Completed by three PE-backed US intermediaries between 2017 and 2025
-
Scale strengthens distributors' negotiating position
Larger distributors gain greater influence
-
Product design matters
Products that better fit distributor platforms may help secure access
The greater demand created by more people actively managing their pensions has attracted new players to the life insurance market, such as private-equity backed intermediaries. The result is that there is consolidation among the companies selling and advising on life insurance. This is creating larger firms with more capacity to invest in technology and adviser support, giving them greater influence over how insurance and retirement products are sold.
Customer access is a source of bargaining power
Insurers and distributors create and capture value in different ways. Insurers provide capital and carry mortality, longevity, market and credit risk. Distributors create value through customer access, advice and relationships, supported by a less capital-intensive business model. As distribution becomes more concentrated within fewer companies, control of these relationships can translate into greater bargaining power.
Consolidation among life insurance distributors is taking different forms across markets. Private equity (PE)-backed companies are building larger independent distribution platforms, banks are integrating life insurance more closely into their networks, and some insurers are selectively reclaiming distribution. In the US, just three private equity-backed independent marketing organisations completed more than 300 publicly announced acquisitions involving distribution businesses between 2017 and 2025.
As distributors gain scale, they can invest more in technology, compliance and adviser productivity while strengthening their negotiating position on remuneration, product access and insurer support. For insurers, this means dealing with fewer, larger counterparties with greater influence over how products reach advisers and customers.
Distribution regulation reinforces the importance of scale
Regulation can reinforce consolidation by raising compliance, technology and oversight costs. Larger insurers and intermediaries are generally better placed to absorb these costs and invest in the capabilities needed to demonstrate strong controls, advice quality and defensible customer outcomes. Regulators are placing greater emphasis on value for money, product governance and the platforms that organise distribution.
How regulation affects distribution varies by market. Regulation can change distribution by modifying adviser remuneration, access to distribution channels and the standards firms must meet. In the UK, for example, commission reform for retail investment products helped change adviser incentives and contributed to consolidation in parts of the advice market. In China, reforms have allowed banks to partner with more insurers, while tighter commission rules have shifted competition towards product value, service and the quality of insurer-bank partnerships.
For insurers, the challenge is therefore to maintain their ability to reach customers on sustainable commercial terms. The appropriate approach will depend on the market and distribution model, from third-party partnerships to more integrated distribution. Product design also matters: products that are easy to compare, administer and integrate into distributor platforms may be better positioned to secure distribution.
Visit sigma explorer for all sigma researches
Disclaimer
Disclaimer
Audio narration of this text is AI generated.